Somebody once told the people running Barnes and Noble that a scrappy little online bookseller would never cut it in the long term. That scrappy little bookseller is now called Amazon.

Picture your own kitchen table for a moment. You have been turning over an online business idea for weeks, something small, something that might bring in a bit of extra income alongside everything else you already do. Then somebody close to you says the three words that stop most people cold: that will never work.

I hear it in different shapes all the time. People tell me, ‘how can I start to earn an extra income,’ and in almost the same breath they tell me a friend, a partner or their own head has already talked them out of trying. The fact that some of the biggest companies on the internet were dismissed by people who should have known better is not just an interesting bit of trivia. It tells you something worth remembering before you shelve your own online business idea.

The Experts Who Got It Spectacularly Wrong

A Barnes and Noble executive once said of Amazon that he did not think it would cut it long term. A well known technology analyst questioned whether Google’s business could ever match its own technology.

Microsoft’s own chief executive laughed off the iPhone, convinced it would never capture any serious market share at that price. eBay was dismissed too, because who would be foolish enough to post a cheque to a complete stranger and wait for a parcel to turn up.

Even PayPal faced the same reaction. Sending money to a stranger online sounded, at the time, like exactly the sort of thing a sensible person would never do.

Airbnb’s own co founder was told, after describing the idea out loud for the first time, that he hoped it was not the only idea he was working on.

Every one of those businesses is now part of ordinary life. Every one of them was, at some point, somebody’s online business idea that a confident expert thought would go nowhere.

Why Confident Doubt Still Sounds Like Truth

Here is the part that catches people out. Doubt does not announce itself as doubt. It arrives dressed as common sense.

The people doing the dismissing in those stories were not fools. They were experienced, successful, and often very good at their jobs. They were simply looking at something new through the lens of what they already understood, and what they already understood did not include an online business idea that had not been tried before.

Doubt, however confident it sounds, is not the same thing as fact.

That matters if you are 45 or older, comfortable enough, but wondering what happens to your family if you are ever made redundant or too ill to work. The voice telling you an idea will not work is rarely speaking from evidence. It is usually speaking from familiarity with how things have always been done.

What This Means If You Are Worried About Redundancy Or Your Pension

I know the questions that sit behind most of this doubt, because readers bring them to me directly. How can I support my family if I am ill and I am the only breadwinner. What will my pension be when I retire, and will it be enough to live on.

Those are not small worries, and nobody should pretend they are. But they are exactly the sort of worries that push people towards something small and steady on the side, rather than away from it.

Think of it this way. A modest idea that earns an extra few hundred dollars a month will not replace a full salary overnight, but it buys you options. It is the difference between a redundancy letter being a crisis and being an inconvenience you can manage. It is the difference between retirement arriving on your terms rather than the pension provider’s. None of that depends on becoming the next Amazon. It depends on starting, however small the first step looks, and refusing to let somebody else’s confident guess talk you out of it before you have even tried.

A modest online business idea, built slowly and properly, is not a reckless gamble. It is a second option sitting quietly in the background, in case the first one ever lets you down.

Listening Without Letting It Stop You

I spent 51 years running my own hairdressing business, and the one thing that stuck with me from all those years is this: listen properly to what somebody really wants before you decide what they need.

That applies to your own doubts as much as anyone else’s opinion. Listen to the fear. Understand where it comes from. Then decide for yourself whether it is a good enough reason to stop, which is a theme I have come back to more than once in other articles I have shared recently.

What I will not do is recommend something to you that I have not seen work for myself or for people I trust. That is underrated in this market. Too many people sell an idea without ever explaining properly what it actually involves, and then offer support that turns out to be hit and miss when you need it most.

I learned the same lesson years before I ever went near a computer. In hairdressing, I invested in courses on cutting, colouring and perming, and every one of them was good. But none of them actually taught me the trade. What made me competent was putting what I had been shown into practice, over and over, until it became natural. The same holds true here: a guide gets you started, but doing the work is what proves whether an idea has legs.

The Small Step That Proves The Doubters Wrong

You do not need Amazon or Airbnb style ambition to get started. You need one small, honest step that tests whether your online business idea has any legs at all.

Write the idea down in one sentence. Write down who it helps and how. Then find one person, even just one, who might really want it, and ask them what they think, properly, the way you would want someone to ask you.

That one sentence does more work than it looks like it should. It forces you to say, out loud, what the idea actually is instead of leaving it as a vague feeling. Most ideas that get abandoned are abandoned before they are ever written down, not because they were tested and failed.

Each day another step is still progress, even when the step feels small enough to be embarrassing. You are not trying to build the whole business in a weekend. You are trying to find out whether the doubt around you is telling you something real, or simply something familiar.

If you do not try, you will get what you have always got. No one is asking you to ignore every piece of advice you are given. They are asking you to stop treating confident doubt as if it were proof.

Where To Learn The Next Step

If you want a simple, structured way to start building an online business idea without a big learning curve, Nick James put together a guide called Six Figures A Year In Information Publishing. It walks through building an information publishing business from a standing start, the same path many people follow into this business.

I am not going to pretend it does everything for you. What I can tell you is that it gives you a proper place to begin, instead of a blank page and a head full of other people’s doubts.

Whatever you decide, do not let somebody else’s confident guess be the reason you never find out. Ask what you do not understand, take the smallest honest step you can, and keep believing in yourself a little more each day.

Best regards

Calling All Frustrated Entrepreneurs –
Who Else Wants To Forget Selling 'Low Priced' One Off Digital Products Such As eBooks And…

Make Cash
Like Clockwork

Using A Passive Income System That Automatically Deposits Money Into Your Bank Account Effortlessly Every Month Instead.

Just enter your details below to discover how:

Privacy Policy: We value your privacy. You can unsubscribe from receiving future emails with 1 click at any time.